Skip to the first action
← Back to Resources

Hire and onboard employees

New-hire I-9s: what to check before the file is closed

A practical review path for completion, document review, corrections, reverification, secure storage, and retention.

For
U.S. employers completing Form I-9
Scope
Federal · United States
Approx. reading time
6-minute read
Reviewed
October 25, 2026

Use this guide when: completing the initial new-hire Form I-9 process or performing the distinct final file review for corrections, storage, retention, and applicable follow-up.

Jump to official materials ↓
Content details

Content ID GUIDE-HIRE-001 · Version 1.5 · Next scheduled review April 25, 2027.

Estimated at 200 words per minute, rounded up. Optional examples and linked sources take extra time. Editorial review confirms structure, source linkage, clarity, and stated boundaries. It is not legal, tax, or other professional review.

Start here

What do you need to do?

Understand the timingSeparate the employee and employer stages.See the formMatch the four callouts to the ordinary workflow.Complete and retain the fileReview documents, corrections, follow-up, and retention.
On this page

The plain-language answer

Initial Form I-9 completion and the employer’s final file review are distinct stages. Complete each required action on time, then use the final review to confirm the record is consistent, corrections are traceable, follow-up is assigned, and storage and retention controls are in place. A later review does not cure a missed deadline.

What you need before starting

  • The employee’s accepted job offer and first day of employment.
  • The current Form I-9, instructions, and Lists of Acceptable Documents.
  • An employer representative assigned to review documents and complete Section 2.
  • A secure retention location and an owner for any follow-up date.

See the form

Four places that control the ordinary new-hire workflow

Follow each numbered arrow from the official form to the matching explanation. The callouts orient the ordinary employee and employer stages; they do not replace the USCIS instructions.

Official USCIS Form I-9 page 1 showing Section 1 and Section 2
Official USCIS Form I-9, page 1. Always confirm the edition shown on the current file before use.
  1. Section 1 timing

    The employee completes and signs Section 1 no later than the first day of employment, after accepting the job offer.

  2. Employee attestation

    The employee selects the applicable status and completes any connected number fields.

  3. Document path

    The employee presents List A, or List B plus List C. The employer does not prescribe a specific document.

  4. Employer certification

    The representative completes the examination, first-day, signature, and employer-information fields on time.

Open the current official Form I-9 ↗ (opens in a new tab)

Complete the ordinary new-hire workflow

  1. Provide the current form and instructions. Confirm the official edition and expiration display, and make the instructions and Lists of Acceptable Documents available.
  2. Employee completes Section 1. The employee completes and signs Section 1 no later than the first day of employment, and not before accepting the job offer.
  3. Employee chooses documentation. Accept either one List A document or an authorized List A combination, or one List B plus one List C document. Apply the same review standard regardless of citizenship, immigration status, or national origin. Do not demand a specific or extra document, or reject otherwise acceptable documentation merely because it has a future expiration date. Route unfamiliar documentation or unresolved concerns to the trained I-9 owner before requesting more documents or making an adverse decision.
  4. Employer examines documents and completes Section 2. Physically examine the documents in the employee’s presence unless the employer is eligible for and follows a current DHS-authorized alternative procedure. Follow current rules for an original document, a permitted certified birth-certificate copy, receipts, and automatic extensions. Attest that the documents appear genuine and relate to the employee. Complete Section 2 within three business days after the first day of work for pay; if employment lasts fewer than three business days, complete it no later than the first day and do not accept a receipt in place of the required document.
  5. Handle exceptions without backdating. The employee corrects Section 1, with preparer or translator assistance documented when applicable; the employer or authorized representative corrects the employer sections. Use actual correction dates, preserve the original information and explanation, and escalate unresolved deadlines, signatures, or discrepancies. A later correction does not make an untimely action timely.
  6. Assign only applicable follow-up. Do not reverify U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals, lawful permanent residents who presented Form I-551, or expired List B documents merely because they expire. Check whether reverification is actually required and whether current extension authority changes the follow-up date.
  7. Store and retain the record. Keep Form I-9 throughout employment and, after employment ends, until the later of three years after hire or one year after termination, subject to preservation requirements. Required copying depends on the examination procedure and E-Verify rules; otherwise apply any document-copy policy consistently and keep restricted identity records by reference rather than duplicating them.

Use Supplement A for preparer or translator assistance and Supplement B only when the current reverification or rehire rules apply. An internal escalation must not delay a deadline.

Illustration: an employee starts on Monday

Illustration only—not a determination for a particular hire. If Monday is the employee’s first day of work for pay, Section 1 is due no later than Monday. Under the ordinary three-business-day rule, the employer generally completes Section 2 by Thursday. Holidays, a job lasting fewer than three business days, unusual documentation, or other facts can change the action; confirm the current USCIS instructions.

Decide

Questions to answer before closing the file

  • Were the employee and employer sections completed within the applicable timing rules?
  • Did the employer accept documents from the permitted lists without prescribing which documents the employee must present?
  • Are names, dates, signatures, document details, and preparer or translator fields complete and internally consistent?
  • If a correction was needed, does the record preserve what changed, who changed it, and when?
  • Is reverification actually required, and does a current automatic extension or other authority change the follow-up date?
  • Are the form and any required or consistently retained copies stored securely with access limited to people who need it?

Action and ownership

HR or onboarding owner

Complete the initial review, resolve omissions promptly, document corrections, and route unresolved questions.

Records owner

Apply the retention calculation, control access, and preserve forms for inspection without mixing unnecessary personal records into the file.

Keep as evidence

Evidence to retain

  • The completed Form I-9 and copies required by the examination procedure or E-Verify rules; otherwise retain optional document copies only under a consistent employer policy.
  • A correction or audit trail where changes were made.
  • Reverification reminders and completion evidence only when applicable.
  • The hire date, termination date, and documented retention calculation.

What completion looks like

Required sections and document examination are complete, corrections are traceable, and applicable follow-up and retention dates have owners. Any missed deadline remains recorded and escalated; later completion does not make the original action timely. Actual completion dates are used and the original record is preserved rather than backdated.

Authoritative sources

Always confirm the current form edition, instructions, source dates, and organization-specific facts before acting.

Escalate

When to escalate

Escalate when documentation appears inconsistent, work authorization is uncertain, discrimination concerns arise, a government inspection or notice is received, or the facts do not fit the ordinary process.

Boundary

What this guide does not cover

This guide does not provide immigration advice, select acceptable documents for an employee, determine work authorization, or resolve organization-specific retention, privacy, or discrimination questions.

Continue the work

What you may need next

Find hiring and onboarding guidanceFind related guidance and the next practical step.Review payroll deposit timingFind related guidance and the next practical step.
Scope and boundaries

Federal Form I-9 workflow for U.S. employers. This overview does not determine how a rule applies to a particular person, document, employer, transaction, or immigration matter.

How corrections and withdrawals are handled →

Controlled content record

Content ID GUIDE-HIRE-001 · Version 1.5 · Last reviewed October 25, 2026 · Next scheduled review April 25, 2027 · Sources last checked October 26, 2026.

Version history: Version 1.5 separates initial completion from final review and adds examination, exception, reverification, retention, and privacy controls.

Suggested citation: Lvl Haus, “New-hire I-9s: what to check before the file is closed,” GUIDE-HIRE-001, v1.5 (last reviewed October 25, 2026).

Report a potential content issue →

Protect sensitive information: Send only the article ID and a nonsensitive description. Do not email forms, identity documents, payroll or bank data, medical or incident records, passwords, or payment information.

Help us improve

Did this help you complete the task?

Choose an answer for this page, or email only the article ID and a nonsensitive description. Do not send forms, identity documents, payroll or bank data, medical or incident records, passwords, or payment information.